Good Canadian inflation news didn't lower fixed rates because Washington got there first
Canada's October inflation held at 3.1%, and once you strip out energy it's sitting below what most forecasters expected. Normally that's the kind of news that nudges fixed rates down a bit.
It didn't. Instead, the 5 year bond yield jumped. Not because of anything that happened here, but because US inflation ran hotter than expected and the Fed is now widely expected to raise rates in December. That pulled Canadian fixed rates along.
So if you're shopping right now, fixed rates are partly being set by a problem that isn't even ours. Good news here got overruled by bad news there. That's the frustrating part about this week.
Variable rates still answer only to the Bank of Canada
That split is the whole story right now. Your variable rate doesn't care what the Fed does.
Three straight months of job losses and soft growth say be patient. A late-October hike and lingering energy pressure say stay cautious. Economists are split right down the middle.
If the Bank does move in December, variable holders feel it in a single quarter-point. That's roughly a small bump per month on a typical mortgage. If it holds, nothing changes until the new year. Either way, a variable rate keeps you plugged into the Canadian story, not the American one.
Variable would have to climb substantially to lose to today's fixed rates
Which brings up the question most people are actually weighing right now. Fixed or variable? The best five-year fixed sits around 4.39% today, and the best variable around 3.65%.
For a variable rate to end up costing more than today's fixed over a full term, it would have to rise substantially from here and stay there. And with our economy going backwards on jobs, I don't think that's the likely path.
The honest trade-off is this. Fixed buys you certainty. You'll know your payment for five years, and in a world this jumpy, plenty of people will pay a bit more for that peace of mind. Variable keeps the door open to benefit from future cuts right away instead of waiting for a renewal date.
There's no wrong answer. Just the one that fits how much payment movement you can actually live with. Pick the payment you can stop thinking about, and get on with your life.
My take
My read: the US-vs-Canada split is the most useful thing to understand right now, and it still tilts me toward variable. Variable would need to climb substantially to lose to today's fixed, and I just don't see a Canada shedding jobs three months running forcing that kind of run. Fixed is getting pushed around by an American inflation problem, not a Canadian one, and I don't love paying more for a risk set in Washington that may never show up here. That said, if you'd lose sleep over a variable payment that moves, fixed is a perfectly rational call. I could be wrong if our inflation starts spreading the way it has down south. That's the one thing I'm watching.
Insider tip
If you're sitting on home equity and carrying a line of credit or card balances, ask us for a blended-rate quote before you assume refinancing is off the table this week. Rolling high-interest debt into the mortgage can drop your total household payment even when the mortgage rate itself ticks up. The math turns on the debt you're killing, not just the headline rate.
Go deeper: Should You Refinance Your Mortgage?
Rates moved. Let's see if your plan should.
Fifteen minutes on the phone with me, no documents. If this week changes nothing for you, I'll tell you that too.
Let's Talk Strategy