Mortgage & Wealth Strategies

REVEALED: The Hidden Costs of a 'Lower Rate' - What the Banks Don’t Want You to Know

January 22, 2025 | Posted by: Matt Broom-Hall

For many homebuyers, the mortgage process feels like a hunt for the lowest possible interest rate. After all, the lower the rate, the more money you’ll save, right? Not quite. There’s a lot more to your mortgage than just the interest rate, and focusing solely on the lowest rate can cost you thousands in the long run.

In this article, I’ll show you how taking a slightly higher rate—paired with strategic monitoring through my exclusive RateWatch+ service—can save you significant money and offer you flexibility the banks won’t.

Case Study 1: Variable Rate with Broker vs. Bank's Lower Rate

Let’s start with a variable rate comparison between two clients: one choosing a slightly higher rate with a broker (me) and the other taking the lowest rate offered by a big bank.

Scenario Breakdown:

• Broker’s Rate: Prime -0.90%

• Bank’s Rate: Prime -1.00%

At first glance, it looks like the bank is offering the better deal with Prime -1.00%. But here’s where things change.

After 1 Year:
With RateWatch+, I actively monitor the mortgage market and notice fixed rates drop after a year. I contact the client and recommend they switch to a fixed rate to lock in long-term savings at no cost. The client takes the advice and reaps the benefits of the lower fixed rate for the remainder of the term. Meanwhile, the bank’s client doesn’t receive any proactive outreach. They stick with their variable rate, and when it’s time for renewal, fixed rates have increased to 6.00%, leaving them to pay more for the remaining term.

Savings Calculation:

• Broker’s Client:

  • Starts at Prime -0.90%

  • Switches to 4.50% fixed for 4 years

  • Total interest paid over 5 years: $58,000

• Bank’s Client:

  • Stays at Prime -1.00%

  • Renews into 6.00% fixed after 5 years

  • Total interest paid over 5 years: $64,500

Total Savings by Working with a Broker (Me): $6,500

Case Study 2: Slightly Higher Fixed Rate vs. Lowest Fixed Rate

Next, let’s take a look at a 5-year fixed rate comparison. The broker’s rate is 10 basis points higher (0.10%) than the big bank’s, but again, the strategy behind that higher rate leads to significant savings.

Scenario Breakdown:

• Broker’s Rate: 5.09%

• Bank’s Rate: 4.99%

The bank’s client locks in at 4.99% and doesn’t hear from their lender for the entire 5-year term. On the other hand, my client gets consistent monitoring through RateWatch+. Two years into the mortgage term, fixed rates drop to 3.50%, and I notify the client that it makes financial sense to break their current mortgage and switch to a lower rate.

The penalty to break the mortgage is $2,500, but with most lenders, this can be rolled into the new mortgage. The client switches to a 3.50% fixed rate for the remaining 3 years.

Savings Calculation:

• Broker’s Client:

  • Starts at 5.09%

  • Pays a $2,500 penalty to switch to 3.50% fixed for the remaining 3 years

  • Monthly savings: $300

  • Total interest paid over 5 years: $68,000

• Bank’s Client:

  • Stays at 4.99% for the full term

  • Total interest paid over 5 years: $72,000

Total Savings by Working with a Broker (Me): $4,000 (even after paying the penalty!)

The Hidden Danger: Big Bank Payout Penalties

Another critical area where big banks hit hard is when you need to break your mortgage early. Big banks use posted rates to calculate their Interest Rate Differential (IRD) penalty, which leads to significantly higher fees than with monoline lenders, which don’t inflate their penalties with posted rates.

Scenario Breakdown:

• Breaking a 5-Year Fixed Mortgage Early:

  • Bank Penalty: $10,000 (calculated using posted rate vs. discount rate)

  • Monoline Lender Penalty: $2,500 (calculated using actual rate)

Savings by Choosing a Broker with Access to Monoline Lenders: $7,500 in penalties!

Why Working with a Broker Pays Off

It’s easy to get lured in by the lowest rate a bank advertises, but as I’ve shown, the true cost of a mortgage is about more than just the interest rate. At Hello Mortgage, I not only help you find a competitive rate, but I also provide strategic guidance through RateWatch+, monitor opportunities to save, and ensure you avoid costly penalties with better mortgage terms.

By taking a slightly higher rate upfront, my clients end up saving thousands over the course of their mortgage. When you work with me, you’re not just getting a mortgage; you’re getting a partner who watches out for your financial future.

Back to Main Blog Page